Step off Fifth Avenue at the corner of 59th Street, right where Central Park begins, and the Sherry-Netherland’s copper-topped tower has been part of the skyline since 1927. Society’s old guard still checks in here, and it’s easy to see why: the lobby alone, with its hand-loomed French carpets and Vanderbilt-mansion plasterwork, feels more like a private club than a hotel.
Every room and suite is individually furnished rather than standardized, so no two stays look quite the same — expect fine antiques, marble baths, and views that stretch over the park’s treetops from the higher floors. A nightly turndown brings Louis Sherry chocolates and fresh flowers, a small ritual the hotel has kept going since its earliest days.
Dowstairs, Harry Cipriani recreates its Venice original almost exactly, right down to the Bellinis, making it one of the more theatrical places on Fifth Avenue for a late lunch. The building’s ground floor also houses a rotating lineup of boutiques, including fine jewelry and leather-goods specialists, so a stroll to the elevator can double as a bit of window shopping.
This is a five-minute walk from the Plaza, the Met’s front steps, and the shopping stretch of Madison Avenue, which makes the Sherry-Netherland a smart base for a classic New York weekend without the crowds of Times Square. The hotel is currently completing exterior facade work required under the city’s building-safety program, so don’t be surprised to see some scaffolding — it doesn’t touch the experience inside.
Complimentary Wi-Fi, a fitness center, elevator and valet service, and a dedicated concierge who can usually find tickets to whatever’s sold out that week round out the stay. For a hotel pushing a century old, it wears its history remarkably lightly.